CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
- akr71
- Award Winner 4
- Posts: 2644
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 7:18 pm
- Name: Andy
- Location: Amherst, NS
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
After making a few phone calls I think I've found a better solution. Given my location, how I'm going to get the tank refilled is a serious consideration. Air Liquide in Moncton will fill my tank Fridays, but prefer a Thurday drop off and Friday pickup. They have drop off point here in Amherst, but that leaves me without a tank (& without beer) for at least a week as they only make a run to Amherst once a week.
Praxair will lease me a 20# cylinder for ~$30/year + product ($38 for a full tank) and when its empty, I just exchange it (and another $38) for a full one. I don't own the tank, I don't need to worry about hydro-testing. I have a hard time believing I would even use 20# in a year.
Feel free to poke holes in my logic... (and yes, I know I start to lose money after year 2).
Praxair will lease me a 20# cylinder for ~$30/year + product ($38 for a full tank) and when its empty, I just exchange it (and another $38) for a full one. I don't own the tank, I don't need to worry about hydro-testing. I have a hard time believing I would even use 20# in a year.
Feel free to poke holes in my logic... (and yes, I know I start to lose money after year 2).
Andy
"Now son, you don't want to drink beer. That's for Daddies, and kids with fake IDs." - Homer J. Simpson
"Now son, you don't want to drink beer. That's for Daddies, and kids with fake IDs." - Homer J. Simpson
- mr x
- Mod Award Winner
- Posts: 13764
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 5:30 pm
- Location: Halifax/New Glasgow
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
I like aluminum if you are buying. The Praxair fill is expensive, but you're right about the usage on a 20 lb tank.
At Alexander Keith's we follow the recipes first developed by the great brewmaster to the absolute letter.
- benwedge
- Verified User
- Posts: 957
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 4:22 pm
- Name: Ben Wedge
- Location: Halifax
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Given that you aren't willing to go a week without your keezer (who is?), have you considered buying two 10# tanks? I know it's double the hydro test and purchase price, but Don Brenton's charges around $25, so you're looking at $50 every five years. I see they want $150 for two 10# tanks, plus probably $50 for shipping. You'll also need to fill the tanks upon arrival. I threw this into my handy investment calculator and it says that with 0% interest, for a period of 10 years, assuming you go through 1.5/yr, you're looking at $60/yr or $66 if you use 8% interest compounded monthly.
If my assumption about 1.5 tanks/year is correct, it looks like owning is better, especially since well maintained tanks will last longer than 10 years, so the cost will be lower.
As for using Don Brenton's for cost, I saw them driving back from PEI today, so I assume they do pickups. I'm guessing Air Liquide is comparable in price. I also set the calculator to fill the tanks and get the hydro test immediately before the other than was empty, but that wouldn't have a huge effect on the cost.
As a further note, I understand 10lb will fill 20 kegs without force carbing them. If someone has a more precise figure, please let me know.
If my assumption about 1.5 tanks/year is correct, it looks like owning is better, especially since well maintained tanks will last longer than 10 years, so the cost will be lower.
As for using Don Brenton's for cost, I saw them driving back from PEI today, so I assume they do pickups. I'm guessing Air Liquide is comparable in price. I also set the calculator to fill the tanks and get the hydro test immediately before the other than was empty, but that wouldn't have a huge effect on the cost.
As a further note, I understand 10lb will fill 20 kegs without force carbing them. If someone has a more precise figure, please let me know.
Brewing right now: whatever is going on tap at Stillwell in a few weeks.
- akr71
- Award Winner 4
- Posts: 2644
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 7:18 pm
- Name: Andy
- Location: Amherst, NS
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Thanks for the info - gives me lots to think about. I found out after work from a friend who works for Heritage Gas said they use Air Liquide and apparently do tank leases too. They just drop their empty tank off at the depot here in Amherst at the beginning of the week and pick up a full tank after the truck does their deliveries.
Two 5# cylinders could work though...
Two 5# cylinders could work though...
Andy
"Now son, you don't want to drink beer. That's for Daddies, and kids with fake IDs." - Homer J. Simpson
"Now son, you don't want to drink beer. That's for Daddies, and kids with fake IDs." - Homer J. Simpson
- moxie
- Verified User
- Posts: 324
- Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2010 1:44 pm
- Name: Patrick
- Location: Dartmouth
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
I've got a 10 pounder to fill up sometime, have there been any changes to the drop off protocol?
- ratchet
- Verified User
- Posts: 491
- Joined: Thu Sep 30, 2010 10:35 pm
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
not that I know of... they usually fill while you wait.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 5602
- Joined: Thu Sep 23, 2010 4:17 pm
- Name: Chris
- Location: Halifax / On The Road Again
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
2 of my 3 visits were "drop-off and come back" instead of "while you wait". Really depends on how busy they are. Hydro testing is always a drop-off affair.
Co-author of Atlantic Canada Beer Blog
-
- Verified User
- Posts: 140
- Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2011 1:44 pm
- Name: Gordon Yorke
- Location: Fall River
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
There were some questions about process.
I dropped by yesterday. Went to the back of unit 12 (the unit farthest from St Marget's Bay Road) dropped off 5lb tank and picked up invoice. Walked around to front of unit 5, paid $20.70 (tax incl) walked back to unit 12 and picked up filled tank.
I dropped by yesterday. Went to the back of unit 12 (the unit farthest from St Marget's Bay Road) dropped off 5lb tank and picked up invoice. Walked around to front of unit 5, paid $20.70 (tax incl) walked back to unit 12 and picked up filled tank.
- benwedge
- Verified User
- Posts: 957
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 4:22 pm
- Name: Ben Wedge
- Location: Halifax
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
20.70? I paid 18.98 two weeks ago for my 5#. Cursed store is on to us and raising prices!gyorke wrote:There were some questions about process.
I dropped by yesterday. Went to the back of unit 12 (the unit farthest from St Marget's Bay Road) dropped off 5lb tank and picked up invoice. Walked around to front of unit 5, paid $20.70 (tax incl) walked back to unit 12 and picked up filled tank.
Brewing right now: whatever is going on tap at Stillwell in a few weeks.
- Brewnoser
- Award Winner 17
- Posts: 723
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 9:11 am
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Brenton's has been doing them all in town forever. I used to take mine there 20 years ago when I first got into kegging. Ronnie Brenton is Steve and Mark Haynes' uncle, and when you do the drop off, pick up thing at any Urban Grape, that's where they go.
I just do that now with my 5 pounder. Take it to Quinpool, leave it and get a new, tested and full one immediately. They little they make off it is worth the service.
I just do that now with my 5 pounder. Take it to Quinpool, leave it and get a new, tested and full one immediately. They little they make off it is worth the service.
----
"Work is the curse of the drinking class." - Oscar Wilde
"Work is the curse of the drinking class." - Oscar Wilde
- benwedge
- Verified User
- Posts: 957
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 4:22 pm
- Name: Ben Wedge
- Location: Halifax
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
I'll pay almost anything to live my entire life on the peninsula. Brewnoser is right about the convenience fee being worth it in this case.Brewnoser wrote:Brenton's has been doing them all in town forever. I used to take mine there 20 years ago when I first got into kegging. Ronnie Brenton is Steve and Mark Haynes' uncle, and when you do the drop off, pick up thing at any Urban Grape, that's where they go.
I just do that now with my 5 pounder. Take it to Quinpool, leave it and get a new, tested and full one immediately. They little they make off it is worth the service.
Brewing right now: whatever is going on tap at Stillwell in a few weeks.
- mr x
- Mod Award Winner
- Posts: 13764
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 5:30 pm
- Location: Halifax/New Glasgow
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
$18.98 for 5lbs this morning. There was about 80 brand new aluminum 5/10/20 lbs tanks just waiting to be filled. They'll be at the NG stores for sure.
At Alexander Keith's we follow the recipes first developed by the great brewmaster to the absolute letter.
- know1
- Award Winner 1
- Posts: 861
- Joined: Tue May 10, 2011 9:59 pm
- Name: Jeramy Slaunwhite
- Location: Sackvegas
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
I have a 20#er kicking around well overdue of a hydro I'm thinking of taking in. Anyone ever have any issues with parts/repairs? If its gonna cost more than the test+fill I'd rather just swap out my 5# at NG
Kegged: El Dorado IPA, Rocketfuel 2.0, Wet Hopped Pale, Ryrish Red, Marzen, BN Exchange Dunkel, BN Exchange NEIPA, Lies Lies Lies - Citra <0.5% ale
Fermenting: NZ Pilsner with Enigma, Strawberry brett cider
Fermenting: NZ Pilsner with Enigma, Strawberry brett cider
- mr x
- Mod Award Winner
- Posts: 13764
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 5:30 pm
- Location: Halifax/New Glasgow
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
I think they either pass or fail, not much to repair. I had one fail, an old steel tank with pitting on the bottom. Scrap metal.
At Alexander Keith's we follow the recipes first developed by the great brewmaster to the absolute letter.
- know1
- Award Winner 1
- Posts: 861
- Joined: Tue May 10, 2011 9:59 pm
- Name: Jeramy Slaunwhite
- Location: Sackvegas
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
makes sense. I assume they still charged you for the test even though it failed?
Kegged: El Dorado IPA, Rocketfuel 2.0, Wet Hopped Pale, Ryrish Red, Marzen, BN Exchange Dunkel, BN Exchange NEIPA, Lies Lies Lies - Citra <0.5% ale
Fermenting: NZ Pilsner with Enigma, Strawberry brett cider
Fermenting: NZ Pilsner with Enigma, Strawberry brett cider
- mr x
- Mod Award Winner
- Posts: 13764
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 5:30 pm
- Location: Halifax/New Glasgow
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
No, they didn't bother even attempting it, failed on the visual. I don't think they would charge you if they scrapped the tank after a bad test.
At Alexander Keith's we follow the recipes first developed by the great brewmaster to the absolute letter.
- KMcK
- Award Winner 1
- Posts: 2342
- Joined: Thu Oct 14, 2010 9:54 pm
- Name: Kyle
- Location: Halifax, Nova Soctia
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Three months in Saint John will do that to a person.benwedge wrote:I'll pay almost anything to live my entire life on the peninsula.
McKeggerator:
- no beer
- benwedge
- Verified User
- Posts: 957
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2010 4:22 pm
- Name: Ben Wedge
- Location: Halifax
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
I said that after a week, but yes.KMcK wrote:Three months in Saint John will do that to a person.benwedge wrote:I'll pay almost anything to live my entire life on the peninsula.
Brewing right now: whatever is going on tap at Stillwell in a few weeks.
-
- Verified User
- Posts: 1414
- Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:38 am
- Name: Tim Gallant
- Location: Kingston, ON
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
My 20 lb'er 'tank pressure' gauge just took a dive the past few days, almost reading nothing. Do I have much time left or should I just bring it in to Brentons today? I'd hate to waste 1/10 of the tank if I'm still good for a few day?
-
- Verified User
- Posts: 1414
- Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:38 am
- Name: Tim Gallant
- Location: Kingston, ON
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Think I figured this out on my own..
http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f35/co2-tan ... pty-12477/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Basically at a certain temp (mine is at ~45degF) all the CO2 is vapour below a certain pressure.. (in my case 600 psi). Mine is below that.. so all vapour, off to Brentons I go!
http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f35/co2-tan ... pty-12477/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Basically at a certain temp (mine is at ~45degF) all the CO2 is vapour below a certain pressure.. (in my case 600 psi). Mine is below that.. so all vapour, off to Brentons I go!
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 5602
- Joined: Thu Sep 23, 2010 4:17 pm
- Name: Chris
- Location: Halifax / On The Road Again
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
As mentioned in another thread, might be good to get in the habit of weighing your tank.
Maybe not exact, but here's a rule of thumb for Aluminum tanks:
Maybe not exact, but here's a rule of thumb for Aluminum tanks:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Co-author of Atlantic Canada Beer Blog
- jeffsmith
- Verified User
- Posts: 4922
- Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2011 4:18 pm
- Name: Jeff Smith
- Location: Amherst, NS
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Anyone know a good spot in Moncton (or area) to get a tank filled? Preferably somewhere that I can get it filled on the spot and don't have to leave it for a few days, I'd like to make one trip do.
- jeffsmith
- Verified User
- Posts: 4922
- Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2011 4:18 pm
- Name: Jeff Smith
- Location: Amherst, NS
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Looks like Brunswick Fyr & Safety in Moncton will do fills and hydro. Will report back with a price for anyone else that may be interested.
-
- Verified User
- Posts: 533
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2010 9:27 pm
- Location: Cape Breton, NS
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Yes, i'd be interested in some prices when you do get them.....for fills and hydro please. So far, i think the cheapest/most reasonable prices i've seen in the maritimes are Don Brenton's.....Moncton would be easier for me if they're close to price as i go there more often.jeffsmith wrote: Will report back with a price for anyone else that may be interested.
- jeffsmith
- Verified User
- Posts: 4922
- Joined: Tue Apr 26, 2011 4:18 pm
- Name: Jeff Smith
- Location: Amherst, NS
- Contact:
Re: CO2 tank refilling and hydro-testing
Forgot to ask about hydro as I didn't need to have it done on my tank. A fill for 10lb. at Brunswick Fyr is $40 taxes in. Not a bad deal considering Air Liquide wants $50 and change and Praxair prefers contract customers.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Magpie [Bot] and 21 guests