So what's the catch?
- jtmwhyte
- Verified User
- Posts: 1934
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:21 pm
- Name: Trevor Whyte
So what's the catch?
I did my first ever BIAB last week scaling back from 2 vessel (Cooler MT and Pot). It seemed way too convenient, easy, and time friendly (3 hours excluding pre-brew list of crushing and measuring). I nailed everything on my brew sheet exactly including volumes, OG, and temps (despite a bit of fucking around to hit mash temp initially, but I didn't account for cold grain. It only took 3 miniutes or so to adjust with my eKettle). Fermentation took off like a bullet with US-05 and finished dead onto the gravity I wanted and the gravity sample tasted great.
Sound too good to be true? I think so too... what's the catch? I've heard that there can be body problems associated with a full mash, but I'm thinking that's a red herring given some of my latest reading.
When things seem too good to be true they usually are, but I can't see myself doing cooler mash ever again if this turns out so great.
So let's hear some problems people have had with BIAB
Sound too good to be true? I think so too... what's the catch? I've heard that there can be body problems associated with a full mash, but I'm thinking that's a red herring given some of my latest reading.
When things seem too good to be true they usually are, but I can't see myself doing cooler mash ever again if this turns out so great.
So let's hear some problems people have had with BIAB
Nova Prime Taproom
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
- Jimmy
- Site Admin Award Winner
- Posts: 6984
- Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2010 6:35 pm
- Location: Halifax, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
It's a solid method that a fair number of the members on here use to brew and I don't think you'd ever find that it produces an inferior beer. The biggest issue I can think of is the size of the pot that's required to do BIAB as compared to multi-vessel setups.
- GuingesRock
- Award Winner 20+
- Posts: 5190
- Joined: Wed May 29, 2013 2:26 pm
- Name: Mark
- Location: Wolfville, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
I've only ever done BIAB. You've done both now. Here's a 3 vessel brewer turned BIABer. He's on Basic Brewing Radio a lot.
-Mark
2nd place, Canadian Brewer of the Year, 2015
101 awards won for beers designed and brewed.
Cicerone Program - Certified Beer Server
2nd place, Canadian Brewer of the Year, 2015
101 awards won for beers designed and brewed.
Cicerone Program - Certified Beer Server
- RubberToe
- Award Winner 13
- Posts: 3743
- Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2011 9:47 am
- Name: Rob
- Location: Dartmouth
- Contact:
Re: So what's the catch?
For me the caveats are:
- More trub, which takes up valuable fermenter space.
- Harder to do 10 gallon batches but I can accomodate. The bag is more unwieldy and harder to squeese. I get slightly less efficiency and a bit higher wort los to absorption vs the 5 gallon batches.
- If I want to go with 15 gallon or larger I'll be doing it with two vessels. I's still do full volume, no sparge.
It's hard to lift a really heavy grain bag and let it drain. A block and tackle is the answer to that.
- More trub, which takes up valuable fermenter space.
- Harder to do 10 gallon batches but I can accomodate. The bag is more unwieldy and harder to squeese. I get slightly less efficiency and a bit higher wort los to absorption vs the 5 gallon batches.
- If I want to go with 15 gallon or larger I'll be doing it with two vessels. I's still do full volume, no sparge.
It's hard to lift a really heavy grain bag and let it drain. A block and tackle is the answer to that.
Electric Brewery Build
On tap at RubberToe's:
Sometimes on a Sunday Belgian Dubbel, Oaked Old Ale, Ordinary Bitter
On tap at RubberToe's:
Sometimes on a Sunday Belgian Dubbel, Oaked Old Ale, Ordinary Bitter
- CorneliusAlphonse
- Award Winner 1
- Posts: 2988
- Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2010 11:28 pm
Re: So what's the catch?
biggest downside is like jimmy said, need almost the same size pot to do a 5gal BIAB as you do to do a 10gal regular batch. and i dunno if anyone does 10 gallon biab (edit - apparently rubbertoe does!). so it works great but doesnt scale up super well. i too find it super convenient and speedy, but also do pot and cooler batches from time to time.
planning: beer for my cousin's wedding
Fermenting: black ipa
Conditioning:
Kegged: barrel barleywine from 2014 - i think i still have this somewhere
Fermenting: black ipa
Conditioning:
Kegged: barrel barleywine from 2014 - i think i still have this somewhere
- Keith
- Award Winner 6
- Posts: 6479
- Joined: Mon Sep 02, 2013 3:55 pm
- Name: Keith
- Location: Lower Sackville, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
Trevor, heard you had success. I'm switching from extract to bias on my next batch. However confused to shit on how to calculate my efficiency.
Brewer, Owner & Operator @ Ol' Biddy's Brew House
![Cheers :cheers2:](./images/smilies/icon_cheers2.gif)
![Cheers :cheers2:](./images/smilies/icon_cheers2.gif)
- jtmwhyte
- Verified User
- Posts: 1934
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:21 pm
- Name: Trevor Whyte
Re: So what's the catch?
Efficiency is just a function of your what your OG is based on your grain bill and volume. I look at it as how close I get to my volume and OG and never really stress out about it anymore. Even on the most horribly inefficient batches I've made great tasting beer.Keith wrote:Trevor, heard you had success. I'm switching from extract to bias on my next batch. However confused to shit on how to calculate my efficiency.
I set my software to 75% usually.
For example, if I build a recipe at 75% efficiency and the OG is supposed to be 1.050 and I hit 1.055 with the same volume then I know I got better efficiency and tweak the numbers in the software to find out what I had. If I got 1.049 I do the same. I'm usually around 77% with cooler MT but my BIAB attempt was dead onto 80%
Nova Prime Taproom
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
- GuingesRock
- Award Winner 20+
- Posts: 5190
- Joined: Wed May 29, 2013 2:26 pm
- Name: Mark
- Location: Wolfville, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
Potential catch ...changing from a system you know well to a different one can take a while to perfect your brewing on the new system. BIAB is simpler so less room for error and it must be easier to go from 3 vessel to BIAB than it would be to make a move the other way. No worries about over-sparging. I spent the longest time doing BIAB plus a 4 gal batch sparge so I could get a double batch from a 16 gal pot. Now I have a 20 gal BIAB mash pot and doing full volume mash. I like to pump into a second boiling pot rather than pulling the bag for my 10 gal batches. Less mess in the kitchen, and I have a boiling pot with a built in cooling coil.
Last edited by GuingesRock on Mon Apr 28, 2014 8:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-Mark
2nd place, Canadian Brewer of the Year, 2015
101 awards won for beers designed and brewed.
Cicerone Program - Certified Beer Server
2nd place, Canadian Brewer of the Year, 2015
101 awards won for beers designed and brewed.
Cicerone Program - Certified Beer Server
- jtmwhyte
- Verified User
- Posts: 1934
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:21 pm
- Name: Trevor Whyte
Re: So what's the catch?
The beauty is I'm using the same pot with the same boil off rate and require the same pre-boil volume, so once I plug the numbers in I get exactly what I need. Electric is super easy to ensure consistent boil off simply by marking the knob where you feel comfortable with boil off.GuingesRock wrote:Potential catch ...changing from a system you know well to a different one can take a while to perfect your brewing on the new system. BIAB is simpler so less room for error and it must be easier to go from 3 vessel to BIAB than it would be to make a move the other way. No worries about over-sparging. I spent the longest time doing BIAB plus a 4 gal batch sparge so I could get a double batch from a 16 gal pot. Now I have a 20 gal BIAB mash pot and doing full volume mash. I like to pump into a second boiling pot rather than pulling the bag.
Nova Prime Taproom
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
- Woody
- Award Winner 4
- Posts: 1182
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 12:39 am
- Name: Derek
- Location: Truro, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
I love BIAB. I have a 15 gallon pot and single batches are a breeze. If I do double batches I can only mash 42-43 litres plus grain in that pot so I need to us my 15 L pot with 12 L plus around 5 lbs of grain I hold back. A larger pot would solve this issue but my efficiency is great and by doing this I save a few lbs in weight when I pull the bag. I use the small pot mash for a little sparge after I pull the bag and pour it over the larger grain bag. I need fermcap as its pretty close to the rim when I start the boil. Higher gravity brews can be harder as it thickens the mash and I can loose efficiency but for my Double IPA's I add some corn sugar to dry it out and it solves that issue.
Last edited by Woody on Mon Apr 28, 2014 9:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- jtmwhyte
- Verified User
- Posts: 1934
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:21 pm
- Name: Trevor Whyte
Re: So what's the catch?
I'm planning to rip out an American Stout this week for my second BIAB. I can't see the necessity of 10 gallon brewing if it only takes 3-4 hours to make a 5.5 gallon batch
Nova Prime Taproom
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
- Woody
- Award Winner 4
- Posts: 1182
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 12:39 am
- Name: Derek
- Location: Truro, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
10 gallon batches can come in handy if you have a friend that wants to split on a batch and it's not that much extra time to do it! Welcome to BIAB, it's addictive and very straight forward.jtmwhyte wrote:I'm planning to rip out an American Stout this week for my second BIAB. I can't see the necessity of 10 gallon brewing if it only takes 3-4 hours to make a 5.5 gallon batch
-
- Verified User
- Posts: 1145
- Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2013 2:25 pm
- Name: Jon S
- Location: Reykjavik, Iceland
Re: So what's the catch?
One catch that is pretty important to me is the mess. There is no way I could have a dripping hot bag of grain around in my kitchen, with my 2 vessel set up, I drain my mashtun into the kettle, empty the spent grains into a garbage bag mess free. Apart from that and the need for larger kettle, I don't see many drawbacks and I might make the switch if I start brewing outside again.
Fermenting: Oud bruin/Vienna Pekko SMaSH
On tap: Nelson dry hopped Berliner/ Scottish Heavy 70-/ NE IPA
- jtmwhyte
- Verified User
- Posts: 1934
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:21 pm
- Name: Trevor Whyte
Re: So what's the catch?
Just did an American Stout. I hit two points over my OG with more volume than expected.
Nova Prime Taproom
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
- Jimmy
- Site Admin Award Winner
- Posts: 6984
- Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2010 6:35 pm
- Location: Halifax, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
My efficiency went up when I switched to BIAB as compared to batch sparging.
- sleepyjamie
- Award Winner 5
- Posts: 2482
- Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 7:05 pm
- Name: jamie
- Location: Calgary
Re: So what's the catch?
TimG and I are doing biab in a cooler. Even easier than traditional biab.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
On Tap:
Falconers Galaxy IPA
Simcoe SMaSH
Topaz SMaSH
Cranberry Rye Saison
Monde Souterrain (Dark Saison)
Falconers Galaxy IPA
Simcoe SMaSH
Topaz SMaSH
Cranberry Rye Saison
Monde Souterrain (Dark Saison)
- Jimmy
- Site Admin Award Winner
- Posts: 6984
- Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2010 6:35 pm
- Location: Halifax, NS
Re: So what's the catch?
Yeah, the cooler BIAB works pretty slick. No lifting the bag, your mash temps are more stable, and you can increase your batch size by adding a "sparge" or using a larger cooler. It was a good trade-off between straight up BIAB and the traditional batch sparge method with a false bottom/manifold.sleepyjamie wrote:TimG and I are doing biab in a cooler. Even easier than traditional biab.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- jtmwhyte
- Verified User
- Posts: 1934
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:21 pm
- Name: Trevor Whyte
Re: So what's the catch?
My 36qt Coleman extreme is set up for this, but I need the wife to make me another bag. The one she made for my pot is awesome enough that I'm making her a pineapple Pale Ale as a reward.Jimmy wrote:Yeah, the cooler BIAB works pretty slick. No lifting the bag, your mash temps are more stable, and you can increase your batch size by adding a "sparge" or using a larger cooler. It was a good trade-off between straight up BIAB and the traditional batch sparge method with a false bottom/manifold.sleepyjamie wrote:TimG and I are doing biab in a cooler. Even easier than traditional biab.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Nova Prime Taproom
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
- jtmwhyte
- Verified User
- Posts: 1934
- Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2012 8:21 pm
- Name: Trevor Whyte
Re: So what's the catch?
I also remembered that I have a 150qt Igloo Marine cooler at the old homestead in Cape Breton. That would be a beast for full volume BIAB with 10 Gallon Batches.
Nova Prime Taproom
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
Tap 1: Festa Brew Scotch Ale
Tap 2:
"Fill with mingled cream and amber,
I will drain that glass again.
Such hilarious visions clamber
Through the chamber of my brain -
Quaintest thoughts - queerist fancies
Come to life and fade away;
What care I how time advances?
I am drinking ale today." ~ Poe
-
- Verified User
- Posts: 390
- Joined: Sun Nov 11, 2012 12:48 am
- Name: Leslie Barr
- Location: Digby NS
Re: So what's the catch?
I don't believe there is a catch. Or at least not one big enough to discourage the average home brewer from biab. I think a lot of brewers are impressed by fancy gear and tend to over complicate things. I think that many American brewers learned to brew from the big breweries post prohibition so a lot of big factory techniques were brought home and are not really nessisary at that scale. If you look at Australia for example it's almost exclusively biab.
I could be wrong but that's my understanding.
I could be wrong but that's my understanding.
Tap 1: Little Pup Pale Ale
Tap 2: Orange Ya Glad I Said Light Beer?
Tap 3: Roof Top Rye-It
Tap 4: Straberry Vanilla Wine Soda
Tap 5: Big Brown Roof Hound
Tap 2: Orange Ya Glad I Said Light Beer?
Tap 3: Roof Top Rye-It
Tap 4: Straberry Vanilla Wine Soda
Tap 5: Big Brown Roof Hound
- BrewG
- Verified User
- Posts: 106
- Joined: Mon Aug 28, 2017 10:09 am
- Name: Gerard
Re: So what's the catch?
I BIAB and love it!!! I have done many batch sparges and have the cooler and tried different ways. BIAB less equipment and simple. I rest my mash bag over the kettle using the center rack from the oven. Then slowly trickle the sparge water over the grains. I get about 80% efficiency with this method.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
- Registered User
- Posts: 5
- Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2015 10:16 am
- Name: Jon
Re: So what's the catch?
Have you found the downside yet?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests